Consultants in Lean Manufacturing Á Manufacturing Strategy

Consultants in Lean & Manufacturing Strategy


lean article mnu lead-in

Accounting & Finance for Lean Manufacturing

Key Issues for Lean Accounting 

The AccountantLean Manufacturing and traditional accounting conflict in several ways. These conflicts often produce considerable difficulties. The roots of this problem lie, largely, in the history of accounting. Johnson and Kaplan's book, Relevance Lost, has much useful background. This page begins our series on Accounting and metrics. It introduces some of the most important accounting-related issues.

Product Costing

Traditional accounting systems track total expenditures well and are accurate in this. Determining the true costs of individual products and components is another matter.

 The primary culprit in distorted product costs is overhead allocation and the primary effect is to undervalue many products and overvalue others. This, in turn, causes managers to make products that could better be outsourced. It also causes under pricing of products that actually lose money.

Activity Based Costing (ABC)

Activity Based Costing attempts to identify the factors that truly drive overhead cost. It then allocates overhead costs with formulae that reflect these "cost drivers". For example, in Purchasing, the activity cost probably relates to the number of line items on the BOM for each product. In Engineering it might relate to the number of engineering changes.

In practice ABC systems are often implemented in complex ways and produce as much confusion as accuracy. Glen Navis' article on Volume Adjusted Costing discusses this and offers a simple alternative for some situations.

Inventory Cost Analysis

While conventional systems often track inventory well, they rarely track the cost of holding it very well. These costs include space, warehouse personnel, insurance, utilities and many other costs. Most of these costs fall into overhead accounts and appear in oversimplified overhead allocation schemes. They are much higher than is commonly recognized.

Micro Costing

In many firms the accounting system integrates with production control, scheduling and inventory systems via MRP or ERP. These systems are often setup to collect time and cost at each individual machine and operation. The assumption is that the more detailed the data collection, the more knowledge is available. This errs on two counts.

  • When data collection becomes a burden, people fake the data, fail to update, or manipulate it.

  • Data is not knowledge, let alone understanding. Often there is so much data that it is difficult to interpret.

A preoccupation with detailed machine-by-machine data does not fit well in a workcell. In cells, one operator may do many operations on a single part, several operators may also work on a single part. Operators may switch tasks in midstream. Finally, different parts often move through one at a time in unpredictable sequences.

The inability to collect detailed data in a manufacturing cell is sometimes a roadblock to implementation. But all this data collection is non-value added activity and, in workcells,  unnecessary.

Non-Financial Metrics

The foremost goal of business is usually profit. Other goals such as growth, future profitability, and future competitiveness follow closely behind. The volatile nature of the present business environment requires people, systems and organizations that cope effectively with change. But, Traditional accounting does not effectively measure investment in these longer range objectives.

Profit measures are the end result of a long string of activities that create and market the products. These profit measures, alone, are inadequate to control and manage upstream activities.

Running a business for the long term requires more than financial metrics. Individual activities, processes and parameters within each activity or process step require metrics that are, mostly, non-dollar units.

Robert S. Kaplan, David P. Norton, in their book, "The Balanced Scorecard" show how to link metrics and strategy. They provide a system for investing in customers, employees, new product development, and in systems-- not just pumping up short-term earnings with myopic maneuvers.

■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■

Contact Webmaster

©_Permissions

SEP 2007  

Strategos-International:  North America - Europe - Australia

Strategos Footer

Lean Briefing Logo

The Free Newsletter

of Lean

Manufacturing Strategy

Lean Briefing Archives

The Strategos Guide To Value Stream and Process Mapping goes far beyond symbols and arrows. In over 163 pages it tells the reader not only how to do it but what to do with it. More info...

Strategos Guide to Value Stream & Process Mapping